Cross-model continuation · one selected public session

Retrieve the history.
Check the delivered program.

Qwen3-4B continues a recorded Qwen3-8B implementation, with or without agent-requested Funes MCP retrieval. Inspect what was recovered, what the agent did, and what independent execution actually accepted.

The task normalizes coordinates and clocks in robot recordings. Review the centimeter and millimeter coordinate checks alongside the protocol outputs: the diagnostic checks responses; the independent grader checks the numbers.

0 / 6tasks fully resolved
6successful native retrieval results
0 / 6starter programs changed

The supplied program scores 87.5% in a separate preflight under the current grader. All six attempts remain visible, including unchanged programs and errors. A successful retrieval or an agent's finish signal is separate from task acceptance. Inspect the starter check.

Follow the actual retrieval route

  1. Local model
  2. JSONL recorder
  3. Scoped MCP server
  4. Native Funes MCP

The experiment uses the standard MCP entrypoint provided in Skills Anywhere's source example. The recorder retains both negotiated protocol eras and native responses. Memory paths and session IDs are fixed to the reviewed source.

Selected session: evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913
Source manifest SHA-256: 40ae2debeef57610aaacf01b4f086eba2b926cceece9bfcc81c6d051b121d925
Prior agent record · Prior program · Source inventory · Actual MCP and missing-source controls

Compare all six continuations

Both conditions share the task, prior program, initial instructions, protocol diagnostic and interaction budget. Memory tools are available only in the Funes condition. Three model seeds are paired in alternating order.

One public development task · independent execution under two public evaluation seeds
Condition / seedScoreTaskRetrievedWritesCommands
No memory · 1787.5%Unresolved000
Funes MCP · 1787.5%Unresolved202
Funes MCP · 4187.5%Unresolved202
No memory · 4187.5%Unresolved000
No memory · 9787.5%Unresolved000
Funes MCP · 9787.5%Unresolved202

01 / No memory · seed 17

87.5% · Unresolved

Harness stop
finished
Program state
Unchanged
Memory attempts / retrieved
0 / 0
Memory errors
0
Command attempts
0
Command attempts also seen in prior
0
Repeated commands within this attempt
0
Identical writes seen in prior
0
Repeated writes within this attempt
0
Generated tokens
37
Interaction time
4.8 s
Inspect 2 tool calls
  1. read_file
    {
      "path": "/workspace/main.py"
    }
  2. finish
    {}
Inspect 4 failed cases
  • seed 41 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 41 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates
  • seed 97 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 97 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates

Trial JSON · Program · Independent grade

02 / Funes MCP · seed 17

87.5% · Unresolved

Harness stop
finished
Program state
Unchanged
Memory attempts / retrieved
2 / 2
Memory errors
0
Command attempts
2
Command attempts also seen in prior
1
Repeated commands within this attempt
0
Identical writes seen in prior
0
Repeated writes within this attempt
0
Generated tokens
153
Interaction time
37.7 s
Inspect 6 tool calls
  1. recall_prior_session · retrieved
    {
      "query": "Implement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities."
    }
    Read retrieved text and source identity
    {
      "status": "retrieved",
      "text": "[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- text  score=0.999\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 2 --to 8 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"# Robot recording evidence review\\n\\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\\n\\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\\n\\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\\n  acceleration in world metres and seconds.\\n- `observations` contains objects with `frame`, `tick`, `position`, and `velocity`.\\n  Input order is arbitrary. Some expected frames may be absent. The queried\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- text  score=0.997\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 0 --to 4 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\nImplement the robot recording evidence review service described in TASK.md.\nThe program must process any valid input under that contract, not just example.jsonl.\n\nThe authoritative task contract follows:\n\n# Robot recording evidence review\n\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\n\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\n\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- tool_use  score=0.814\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 5 --to 11 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\n[tool_use write_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\",\"content\":\"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    # Extract the query frame\\n    query_frame = request[\\\"query_frame\\\"]\\n    recording = request[\\\"recording\\\"]\\n    source_sha256 = recording[\\\"source\\\"][\\\"sha256\\\"]\\n    metadata = recording[\\\"metadata\\\"]\\n    observations = recording[\\\"observations\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process metadata\\n    expected_frames = metadata[\\\"expected_frames\\\"]\\n    world_from_sensor = metadata[\\\"world_from_sensor\\\"]\\n    axes = world_from_sensor[\\\"axes\\\"]\\n    signs = world_from_sensor[\\\"signs\\\"]\\n    origin_m = world_from_sensor[\\\"origin_m\\\"]\\n    meters_per_unit = world_from_sensor[\\\"meters_per_unit\\\"]\\n    clock = metadata[\\\"clock\\\"]\\n    origin_tick = clock[\\\"origin_tick\\\"]\\n    seconds_per_tick = clock[\\\"seconds_per_tick\\\"]\\n    analytic = metadata[\\\"analytic\\\"]\\n    position0_m = analytic[\\\"position0_m\\\"]\\n    velocity0_m_s = analytic[\\\"velocity0_m_s\\\"]\\n    gravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- tool_use  score=0.306\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 5 --to 11 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\ngravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n    available_frames = sorted(observations_dict.keys())\\n\\n    # Calculate time_seconds for the query frame\\n    query_tick = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"tick\\\"]\\n    time_seconds = (query_tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n\\n    # Calculate position_m for the query frame\\n    query_position = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"position\\\"]\\n    position_m = [\\n        query_position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n        query_position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n        query_position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n    ]\\n\\n    # Calculate speed_m_s for the query frame\\n    query_velocity = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"velocity\\\"]\\n    speed_m_s = (query_velocity[axes[0]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[1]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[2]] ** 2) ** 0.5\\n\\n    # Calculate max_position_error_m\\n    max_position_error_m = 0.0\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        tick = obs[\\\"tick\\\"]\\n        position =\n---\n",
      "passages": [
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 2,
          "to": 8
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 0,
          "to": 4
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 5,
          "to": 11
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 5,
          "to": 11
        }
      ],
      "source": {
        "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
        "manifest_sha256": "40ae2debeef57610aaacf01b4f086eba2b926cceece9bfcc81c6d051b121d925",
        "prior_trial_sha256": "2f665fd5734bb89435224913d43b4a69d91d53495c33d5ba9c375d2c59710004",
        "prior_program_sha256": "0f8d610ce4894ef43620e6f356a39c79775a09a4613b61e6e9818f34371bbf2a",
        "parquet_sha256": "4f38babfcd1c0fb84eac003667d0ac465f2024068c8616cc38a3da44e4f9ca4e"
      }
    }
  2. read_prior_turns · retrieved
    {
      "from": 5,
      "to": 11
    }
    Read retrieved text and source identity
    {
      "status": "retrieved",
      "text": "[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq5 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-5\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"# Robot recording evidence review\\n\\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\\n\\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\\n\\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\\n  acceleration in world metres and seconds.\\n- `observations` contains objects with `frame`, `tick`, `position`, and `velocity`.\\n  Input order is arbitrary. Some expected frames may be absent. The queried frame\\n  is present. Do not interpolate absent observations.\\n\\nReturn exactly `{\\\"ok\\\": true, \\\"report\\\": {...}}`. The report contains these fields:\\n\\n| Field | Required value |\\n| --- | --- |\\n| `source_sha256` | The provided original source digest |\\n| `frame` | The requested integer frame |\\n| `time_seconds` | Its elapsed time, after clock conversion |\\n| `position_m` | Its three world-coordinate position components |\\n| `speed_m_s` | Euclidean magnitude of its world velocity |\\n| `max_position_error_m` | Maximum Euclidean position error across **available** observations against `p0 + v0*t + 0.5*g*t*t` |\\n| `peak_frame` | Available frame with greatest world z; choose the lowest frame number on an exact tie |\\n| `peak_height_m` | That frame's world z position |\\n| `missing_frames` | Sorted list of expected but absent integer frames |\\n\\nUse JSON numbers for numerical values, never Boolean substitutes, NaN or Infinity.\\nChecks allow absolute numerical error up to 1e-6 or relative error up to 1e-7.\\nDo not infer metres, seconds, axis order, or completeness from filenames.\\n\\nThese inputs are derived representations of six real CUDA recordings published\\nby Robot Reel. Unit, coordinate, clock and omission variants are generated for this\\npublic development task. They are not new physical experiments or hidden test data.\\nReporting a source digest provides attribution; it does not authenticate the\\noriginal recording's producer.\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq6 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-6\n[tool_use read_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq7 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-7\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    raise NotImplementedError(\\\"Convert recorded observations and return the requested facts\\\")\\n\\n\\nfor line in sys.stdin:\\n    print(json.dumps({\\\"ok\\\": True, \\\"report\\\": review(json.loads(line))}), flush=True)\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq8 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-8\n[tool_use write_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\",\"content\":\"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    # Extract the query frame\\n    query_frame = request[\\\"query_frame\\\"]\\n    recording = request[\\\"recording\\\"]\\n    source_sha256 = recording[\\\"source\\\"][\\\"sha256\\\"]\\n    metadata = recording[\\\"metadata\\\"]\\n    observations = recording[\\\"observations\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process metadata\\n    expected_frames = metadata[\\\"expected_frames\\\"]\\n    world_from_sensor = metadata[\\\"world_from_sensor\\\"]\\n    axes = world_from_sensor[\\\"axes\\\"]\\n    signs = world_from_sensor[\\\"signs\\\"]\\n    origin_m = world_from_sensor[\\\"origin_m\\\"]\\n    meters_per_unit = world_from_sensor[\\\"meters_per_unit\\\"]\\n    clock = metadata[\\\"clock\\\"]\\n    origin_tick = clock[\\\"origin_tick\\\"]\\n    seconds_per_tick = clock[\\\"seconds_per_tick\\\"]\\n    analytic = metadata[\\\"analytic\\\"]\\n    position0_m = analytic[\\\"position0_m\\\"]\\n    velocity0_m_s = analytic[\\\"velocity0_m_s\\\"]\\n    gravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n    available_frames = sorted(observations_dict.keys())\\n\\n    # Calculate time_seconds for the query frame\\n    query_tick = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"tick\\\"]\\n    time_seconds = (query_tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n\\n    # Calculate position_m for the query frame\\n    query_position = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"position\\\"]\\n    position_m = [\\n        query_position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n        query_position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n        query_position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n    ]\\n\\n    # Calculate speed_m_s for the query frame\\n    query_velocity = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"velocity\\\"]\\n    speed_m_s = (query_velocity[axes[0]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[1]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[2]] ** 2) ** 0.5\\n\\n    # Calculate max_position_error_m\\n    max_position_error_m = 0.0\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        tick = obs[\\\"tick\\\"]\\n        position = obs[\\\"position\\\"]\\n        # Convert position to world coordinates\\n        world_position = [\\n            position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n            position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n            position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n        ]\\n        # Calculate expected position using analytic model\\n        t = (tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n        expected_position = [\\n            position0_m[0] + velocity0_m_s[0] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[0] * t ** 2,\\n            position0_m[1] + velocity0_m_s[1] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[1] * t ** 2,\\n            position0_m[2] + velocity0_m_s[2] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[2] * t ** 2\\n        ]\\n        # Calculate position error\\n        error = (world_position[0] - expected_position[0]) ** 2 + (world_position[1] - expected_position[1]) ** 2 + (world_position[2] - expected_position[2]) ** 2\\n        error = error ** 0.5\\n        if error > max_position_error_m:\\n            max_position_error_m = error\\n\\n    # Find peak_frame and peak_height_m\\n    peak_frame = None\\n    peak_height_m = -float('inf')\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        position = obs[\\\"position\\\"]\\n        # Convert position to world coordinates\\n        world_position = [\\n            position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n            position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n            position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n        ]\\n        if world_position[2] > peak_height_m:\\n            peak_height_m = world_position[2]\\n            peak_frame = frame\\n        elif world_position[2] == peak_height_m:\\n            if frame < peak_frame:\\n                peak_frame = frame\\n\\n    # Find missing_frames\\n    missing_frames = []\\n    for frame in expected_frames:\\n        if frame not in observations_dict:\\n            missing_frames.append(frame)\\n    missing_frames.sort()\\n\\n    # Create report\\n    report = {\\n        \\\"source_sha256\\\": source_sha256,\\n        \\\"frame\\\": query_frame,\\n        \\\"time_seconds\\\": time_seconds,\\n        \\\"position_m\\\": position_m,\\n        \\\"speed_m_s\\\": speed_m_s,\\n        \\\"max_position_error_m\\\": max_position_error_m,\\n        \\\"peak_frame\\\": peak_frame,\\n        \\\"peak_height_m\\\": peak_height_m,\\n        \\\"missing_frames\\\": missing_frames\\n    }\\n    return report\\n\\n\\nfor line in sys.stdin:\\n    print(json.dumps({\\\"ok\\\": True, \\\"report\\\": review(json.loads(line))}), flush=True)\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq9 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-9\n{\"ok\": true, \"written_bytes\": 4547}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq10 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-10\n[tool_use run_command] {\"command\":\"python3 /workspace/main.py < /workspace/example.jsonl\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq11 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-11\n{\"ok\": true, \"exit_code\": 0, \"output\": \"{\\\"ok\\\": true, \\\"report\\\": {\\\"source_sha256\\\": \\\"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\\\", \\\"frame\\\": 31, \\\"time_seconds\\\": 1.033333333333372, \\\"position_m\\\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \\\"speed_m_s\\\": 2004.6877195638112, \\\"max_position_error_m\\\": 0.02046407548115492, \\\"peak_frame\\\": 31, \\\"peak_height_m\\\": 6.085323333740234, \\\"missing_frames\\\": []}}\\n\", \"limit_reached\": null}\n---\nturns 5-11 of 14\n",
      "turns": [
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9,
        10,
        11
      ],
      "source": {
        "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
        "manifest_sha256": "40ae2debeef57610aaacf01b4f086eba2b926cceece9bfcc81c6d051b121d925",
        "prior_trial_sha256": "2f665fd5734bb89435224913d43b4a69d91d53495c33d5ba9c375d2c59710004",
        "prior_program_sha256": "0f8d610ce4894ef43620e6f356a39c79775a09a4613b61e6e9818f34371bbf2a",
        "parquet_sha256": "4f38babfcd1c0fb84eac003667d0ac465f2024068c8616cc38a3da44e4f9ca4e"
      }
    }
  3. read_file
    {
      "path": "/workspace/main.py"
    }
  4. run_command
    {
      "command": "python3 /workspace/main.py < /workspace/example.jsonl"
    }
    Inspect command output
    {
      "ok": true,
      "exit_code": 0,
      "output": "{\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}\n",
      "limit_reached": null
    }
  5. run_command
    {
      "command": "python3 protocol_probe.py"
    }
    Inspect command output
    {
      "ok": true,
      "exit_code": 0,
      "output": "{\"protocol_ok\": true, \"requests\": 2, \"responses\": [{\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}, {\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}], \"numerical_correctness\": \"not_assessed\"}\n",
      "limit_reached": null
    }
  6. finish
    {}
Inspect 4 failed cases
  • seed 41 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 41 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates
  • seed 97 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 97 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates

Trial JSON · Program · Independent grade

03 / Funes MCP · seed 41

87.5% · Unresolved

Harness stop
finished
Program state
Unchanged
Memory attempts / retrieved
2 / 2
Memory errors
0
Command attempts
2
Command attempts also seen in prior
1
Repeated commands within this attempt
0
Identical writes seen in prior
0
Repeated writes within this attempt
0
Generated tokens
153
Interaction time
33.5 s
Inspect 6 tool calls
  1. recall_prior_session · retrieved
    {
      "query": "Implement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities."
    }
    Read retrieved text and source identity
    {
      "status": "retrieved",
      "text": "[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- text  score=0.999\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 2 --to 8 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"# Robot recording evidence review\\n\\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\\n\\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\\n\\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\\n  acceleration in world metres and seconds.\\n- `observations` contains objects with `frame`, `tick`, `position`, and `velocity`.\\n  Input order is arbitrary. Some expected frames may be absent. The queried\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- text  score=0.997\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 0 --to 4 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\nImplement the robot recording evidence review service described in TASK.md.\nThe program must process any valid input under that contract, not just example.jsonl.\n\nThe authoritative task contract follows:\n\n# Robot recording evidence review\n\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\n\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\n\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- tool_use  score=0.814\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 5 --to 11 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\n[tool_use write_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\",\"content\":\"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    # Extract the query frame\\n    query_frame = request[\\\"query_frame\\\"]\\n    recording = request[\\\"recording\\\"]\\n    source_sha256 = recording[\\\"source\\\"][\\\"sha256\\\"]\\n    metadata = recording[\\\"metadata\\\"]\\n    observations = recording[\\\"observations\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process metadata\\n    expected_frames = metadata[\\\"expected_frames\\\"]\\n    world_from_sensor = metadata[\\\"world_from_sensor\\\"]\\n    axes = world_from_sensor[\\\"axes\\\"]\\n    signs = world_from_sensor[\\\"signs\\\"]\\n    origin_m = world_from_sensor[\\\"origin_m\\\"]\\n    meters_per_unit = world_from_sensor[\\\"meters_per_unit\\\"]\\n    clock = metadata[\\\"clock\\\"]\\n    origin_tick = clock[\\\"origin_tick\\\"]\\n    seconds_per_tick = clock[\\\"seconds_per_tick\\\"]\\n    analytic = metadata[\\\"analytic\\\"]\\n    position0_m = analytic[\\\"position0_m\\\"]\\n    velocity0_m_s = analytic[\\\"velocity0_m_s\\\"]\\n    gravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- tool_use  score=0.306\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 5 --to 11 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\ngravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n    available_frames = sorted(observations_dict.keys())\\n\\n    # Calculate time_seconds for the query frame\\n    query_tick = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"tick\\\"]\\n    time_seconds = (query_tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n\\n    # Calculate position_m for the query frame\\n    query_position = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"position\\\"]\\n    position_m = [\\n        query_position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n        query_position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n        query_position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n    ]\\n\\n    # Calculate speed_m_s for the query frame\\n    query_velocity = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"velocity\\\"]\\n    speed_m_s = (query_velocity[axes[0]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[1]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[2]] ** 2) ** 0.5\\n\\n    # Calculate max_position_error_m\\n    max_position_error_m = 0.0\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        tick = obs[\\\"tick\\\"]\\n        position =\n---\n",
      "passages": [
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 2,
          "to": 8
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 0,
          "to": 4
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 5,
          "to": 11
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 5,
          "to": 11
        }
      ],
      "source": {
        "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
        "manifest_sha256": "40ae2debeef57610aaacf01b4f086eba2b926cceece9bfcc81c6d051b121d925",
        "prior_trial_sha256": "2f665fd5734bb89435224913d43b4a69d91d53495c33d5ba9c375d2c59710004",
        "prior_program_sha256": "0f8d610ce4894ef43620e6f356a39c79775a09a4613b61e6e9818f34371bbf2a",
        "parquet_sha256": "4f38babfcd1c0fb84eac003667d0ac465f2024068c8616cc38a3da44e4f9ca4e"
      }
    }
  2. read_prior_turns · retrieved
    {
      "from": 5,
      "to": 11
    }
    Read retrieved text and source identity
    {
      "status": "retrieved",
      "text": "[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq5 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-5\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"# Robot recording evidence review\\n\\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\\n\\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\\n\\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\\n  acceleration in world metres and seconds.\\n- `observations` contains objects with `frame`, `tick`, `position`, and `velocity`.\\n  Input order is arbitrary. Some expected frames may be absent. The queried frame\\n  is present. Do not interpolate absent observations.\\n\\nReturn exactly `{\\\"ok\\\": true, \\\"report\\\": {...}}`. The report contains these fields:\\n\\n| Field | Required value |\\n| --- | --- |\\n| `source_sha256` | The provided original source digest |\\n| `frame` | The requested integer frame |\\n| `time_seconds` | Its elapsed time, after clock conversion |\\n| `position_m` | Its three world-coordinate position components |\\n| `speed_m_s` | Euclidean magnitude of its world velocity |\\n| `max_position_error_m` | Maximum Euclidean position error across **available** observations against `p0 + v0*t + 0.5*g*t*t` |\\n| `peak_frame` | Available frame with greatest world z; choose the lowest frame number on an exact tie |\\n| `peak_height_m` | That frame's world z position |\\n| `missing_frames` | Sorted list of expected but absent integer frames |\\n\\nUse JSON numbers for numerical values, never Boolean substitutes, NaN or Infinity.\\nChecks allow absolute numerical error up to 1e-6 or relative error up to 1e-7.\\nDo not infer metres, seconds, axis order, or completeness from filenames.\\n\\nThese inputs are derived representations of six real CUDA recordings published\\nby Robot Reel. Unit, coordinate, clock and omission variants are generated for this\\npublic development task. They are not new physical experiments or hidden test data.\\nReporting a source digest provides attribution; it does not authenticate the\\noriginal recording's producer.\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq6 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-6\n[tool_use read_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq7 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-7\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    raise NotImplementedError(\\\"Convert recorded observations and return the requested facts\\\")\\n\\n\\nfor line in sys.stdin:\\n    print(json.dumps({\\\"ok\\\": True, \\\"report\\\": review(json.loads(line))}), flush=True)\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq8 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-8\n[tool_use write_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\",\"content\":\"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    # Extract the query frame\\n    query_frame = request[\\\"query_frame\\\"]\\n    recording = request[\\\"recording\\\"]\\n    source_sha256 = recording[\\\"source\\\"][\\\"sha256\\\"]\\n    metadata = recording[\\\"metadata\\\"]\\n    observations = recording[\\\"observations\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process metadata\\n    expected_frames = metadata[\\\"expected_frames\\\"]\\n    world_from_sensor = metadata[\\\"world_from_sensor\\\"]\\n    axes = world_from_sensor[\\\"axes\\\"]\\n    signs = world_from_sensor[\\\"signs\\\"]\\n    origin_m = world_from_sensor[\\\"origin_m\\\"]\\n    meters_per_unit = world_from_sensor[\\\"meters_per_unit\\\"]\\n    clock = metadata[\\\"clock\\\"]\\n    origin_tick = clock[\\\"origin_tick\\\"]\\n    seconds_per_tick = clock[\\\"seconds_per_tick\\\"]\\n    analytic = metadata[\\\"analytic\\\"]\\n    position0_m = analytic[\\\"position0_m\\\"]\\n    velocity0_m_s = analytic[\\\"velocity0_m_s\\\"]\\n    gravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n    available_frames = sorted(observations_dict.keys())\\n\\n    # Calculate time_seconds for the query frame\\n    query_tick = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"tick\\\"]\\n    time_seconds = (query_tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n\\n    # Calculate position_m for the query frame\\n    query_position = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"position\\\"]\\n    position_m = [\\n        query_position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n        query_position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n        query_position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n    ]\\n\\n    # Calculate speed_m_s for the query frame\\n    query_velocity = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"velocity\\\"]\\n    speed_m_s = (query_velocity[axes[0]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[1]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[2]] ** 2) ** 0.5\\n\\n    # Calculate max_position_error_m\\n    max_position_error_m = 0.0\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        tick = obs[\\\"tick\\\"]\\n        position = obs[\\\"position\\\"]\\n        # Convert position to world coordinates\\n        world_position = [\\n            position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n            position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n            position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n        ]\\n        # Calculate expected position using analytic model\\n        t = (tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n        expected_position = [\\n            position0_m[0] + velocity0_m_s[0] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[0] * t ** 2,\\n            position0_m[1] + velocity0_m_s[1] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[1] * t ** 2,\\n            position0_m[2] + velocity0_m_s[2] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[2] * t ** 2\\n        ]\\n        # Calculate position error\\n        error = (world_position[0] - expected_position[0]) ** 2 + (world_position[1] - expected_position[1]) ** 2 + (world_position[2] - expected_position[2]) ** 2\\n        error = error ** 0.5\\n        if error > max_position_error_m:\\n            max_position_error_m = error\\n\\n    # Find peak_frame and peak_height_m\\n    peak_frame = None\\n    peak_height_m = -float('inf')\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        position = obs[\\\"position\\\"]\\n        # Convert position to world coordinates\\n        world_position = [\\n            position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n            position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n            position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n        ]\\n        if world_position[2] > peak_height_m:\\n            peak_height_m = world_position[2]\\n            peak_frame = frame\\n        elif world_position[2] == peak_height_m:\\n            if frame < peak_frame:\\n                peak_frame = frame\\n\\n    # Find missing_frames\\n    missing_frames = []\\n    for frame in expected_frames:\\n        if frame not in observations_dict:\\n            missing_frames.append(frame)\\n    missing_frames.sort()\\n\\n    # Create report\\n    report = {\\n        \\\"source_sha256\\\": source_sha256,\\n        \\\"frame\\\": query_frame,\\n        \\\"time_seconds\\\": time_seconds,\\n        \\\"position_m\\\": position_m,\\n        \\\"speed_m_s\\\": speed_m_s,\\n        \\\"max_position_error_m\\\": max_position_error_m,\\n        \\\"peak_frame\\\": peak_frame,\\n        \\\"peak_height_m\\\": peak_height_m,\\n        \\\"missing_frames\\\": missing_frames\\n    }\\n    return report\\n\\n\\nfor line in sys.stdin:\\n    print(json.dumps({\\\"ok\\\": True, \\\"report\\\": review(json.loads(line))}), flush=True)\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq9 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-9\n{\"ok\": true, \"written_bytes\": 4547}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq10 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-10\n[tool_use run_command] {\"command\":\"python3 /workspace/main.py < /workspace/example.jsonl\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq11 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-11\n{\"ok\": true, \"exit_code\": 0, \"output\": \"{\\\"ok\\\": true, \\\"report\\\": {\\\"source_sha256\\\": \\\"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\\\", \\\"frame\\\": 31, \\\"time_seconds\\\": 1.033333333333372, \\\"position_m\\\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \\\"speed_m_s\\\": 2004.6877195638112, \\\"max_position_error_m\\\": 0.02046407548115492, \\\"peak_frame\\\": 31, \\\"peak_height_m\\\": 6.085323333740234, \\\"missing_frames\\\": []}}\\n\", \"limit_reached\": null}\n---\nturns 5-11 of 14\n",
      "turns": [
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9,
        10,
        11
      ],
      "source": {
        "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
        "manifest_sha256": "40ae2debeef57610aaacf01b4f086eba2b926cceece9bfcc81c6d051b121d925",
        "prior_trial_sha256": "2f665fd5734bb89435224913d43b4a69d91d53495c33d5ba9c375d2c59710004",
        "prior_program_sha256": "0f8d610ce4894ef43620e6f356a39c79775a09a4613b61e6e9818f34371bbf2a",
        "parquet_sha256": "4f38babfcd1c0fb84eac003667d0ac465f2024068c8616cc38a3da44e4f9ca4e"
      }
    }
  3. read_file
    {
      "path": "/workspace/main.py"
    }
  4. run_command
    {
      "command": "python3 /workspace/main.py < /workspace/example.jsonl"
    }
    Inspect command output
    {
      "ok": true,
      "exit_code": 0,
      "output": "{\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}\n",
      "limit_reached": null
    }
  5. run_command
    {
      "command": "python3 protocol_probe.py"
    }
    Inspect command output
    {
      "ok": true,
      "exit_code": 0,
      "output": "{\"protocol_ok\": true, \"requests\": 2, \"responses\": [{\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}, {\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}], \"numerical_correctness\": \"not_assessed\"}\n",
      "limit_reached": null
    }
  6. finish
    {}
Inspect 4 failed cases
  • seed 41 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 41 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates
  • seed 97 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 97 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates

Trial JSON · Program · Independent grade

04 / No memory · seed 41

87.5% · Unresolved

Harness stop
finished
Program state
Unchanged
Memory attempts / retrieved
0 / 0
Memory errors
0
Command attempts
0
Command attempts also seen in prior
0
Repeated commands within this attempt
0
Identical writes seen in prior
0
Repeated writes within this attempt
0
Generated tokens
37
Interaction time
3.3 s
Inspect 2 tool calls
  1. read_file
    {
      "path": "/workspace/main.py"
    }
  2. finish
    {}
Inspect 4 failed cases
  • seed 41 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 41 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates
  • seed 97 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 97 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates

Trial JSON · Program · Independent grade

05 / No memory · seed 97

87.5% · Unresolved

Harness stop
finished
Program state
Unchanged
Memory attempts / retrieved
0 / 0
Memory errors
0
Command attempts
0
Command attempts also seen in prior
0
Repeated commands within this attempt
0
Identical writes seen in prior
0
Repeated writes within this attempt
0
Generated tokens
37
Interaction time
3.4 s
Inspect 2 tool calls
  1. read_file
    {
      "path": "/workspace/main.py"
    }
  2. finish
    {}
Inspect 4 failed cases
  • seed 41 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 41 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates
  • seed 97 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 97 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates

Trial JSON · Program · Independent grade

06 / Funes MCP · seed 97

87.5% · Unresolved

Harness stop
finished
Program state
Unchanged
Memory attempts / retrieved
2 / 2
Memory errors
0
Command attempts
2
Command attempts also seen in prior
1
Repeated commands within this attempt
0
Identical writes seen in prior
0
Repeated writes within this attempt
0
Generated tokens
153
Interaction time
33.8 s
Inspect 6 tool calls
  1. recall_prior_session · retrieved
    {
      "query": "Implement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities."
    }
    Read retrieved text and source identity
    {
      "status": "retrieved",
      "text": "[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- text  score=0.999\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 2 --to 8 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"# Robot recording evidence review\\n\\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\\n\\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\\n\\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\\n  acceleration in world metres and seconds.\\n- `observations` contains objects with `frame`, `tick`, `position`, and `velocity`.\\n  Input order is arbitrary. Some expected frames may be absent. The queried\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- text  score=0.997\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 0 --to 4 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\nImplement the robot recording evidence review service described in TASK.md.\nThe program must process any valid input under that contract, not just example.jsonl.\n\nThe authoritative task contract follows:\n\n# Robot recording evidence review\n\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\n\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\n\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- tool_use  score=0.814\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 5 --to 11 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\n[tool_use write_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\",\"content\":\"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    # Extract the query frame\\n    query_frame = request[\\\"query_frame\\\"]\\n    recording = request[\\\"recording\\\"]\\n    source_sha256 = recording[\\\"source\\\"][\\\"sha256\\\"]\\n    metadata = recording[\\\"metadata\\\"]\\n    observations = recording[\\\"observations\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process metadata\\n    expected_frames = metadata[\\\"expected_frames\\\"]\\n    world_from_sensor = metadata[\\\"world_from_sensor\\\"]\\n    axes = world_from_sensor[\\\"axes\\\"]\\n    signs = world_from_sensor[\\\"signs\\\"]\\n    origin_m = world_from_sensor[\\\"origin_m\\\"]\\n    meters_per_unit = world_from_sensor[\\\"meters_per_unit\\\"]\\n    clock = metadata[\\\"clock\\\"]\\n    origin_tick = clock[\\\"origin_tick\\\"]\\n    seconds_per_tick = clock[\\\"seconds_per_tick\\\"]\\n    analytic = metadata[\\\"analytic\\\"]\\n    position0_m = analytic[\\\"position0_m\\\"]\\n    velocity0_m_s = analytic[\\\"velocity0_m_s\\\"]\\n    gravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] evalarc_local_model_pilot -public-demo-robot-recording-review/evalarc- tool_use  score=0.306\n  → get evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913 --from 5 --to 11 --memory /home/dcvuser/work/robot-reel-agents/codex/artifacts/research-completion-20260919/funes-mcp-handoff/source/memory\ngravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n    available_frames = sorted(observations_dict.keys())\\n\\n    # Calculate time_seconds for the query frame\\n    query_tick = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"tick\\\"]\\n    time_seconds = (query_tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n\\n    # Calculate position_m for the query frame\\n    query_position = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"position\\\"]\\n    position_m = [\\n        query_position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n        query_position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n        query_position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n    ]\\n\\n    # Calculate speed_m_s for the query frame\\n    query_velocity = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"velocity\\\"]\\n    speed_m_s = (query_velocity[axes[0]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[1]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[2]] ** 2) ** 0.5\\n\\n    # Calculate max_position_error_m\\n    max_position_error_m = 0.0\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        tick = obs[\\\"tick\\\"]\\n        position =\n---\n",
      "passages": [
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 2,
          "to": 8
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 0,
          "to": 4
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 5,
          "to": 11
        },
        {
          "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
          "from": 5,
          "to": 11
        }
      ],
      "source": {
        "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
        "manifest_sha256": "40ae2debeef57610aaacf01b4f086eba2b926cceece9bfcc81c6d051b121d925",
        "prior_trial_sha256": "2f665fd5734bb89435224913d43b4a69d91d53495c33d5ba9c375d2c59710004",
        "prior_program_sha256": "0f8d610ce4894ef43620e6f356a39c79775a09a4613b61e6e9818f34371bbf2a",
        "parquet_sha256": "4f38babfcd1c0fb84eac003667d0ac465f2024068c8616cc38a3da44e4f9ca4e"
      }
    }
  2. read_prior_turns · retrieved
    {
      "from": 5,
      "to": 11
    }
    Read retrieved text and source identity
    {
      "status": "retrieved",
      "text": "[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq5 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-5\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"# Robot recording evidence review\\n\\nImplement a JSON-lines service that reviews recorded positions and velocities.\\nEach stdin line is one request. Write exactly one JSON response per request to\\nstdout; diagnostics belong on stderr. Exit cleanly when stdin reaches EOF.\\n\\nThe input contains an `op` of `review`, a `query_frame`, and a `recording`:\\n\\n- `source.sha256` identifies the original recorded file. Preserve it in the report.\\n- `metadata.expected_frames` lists every frame that should be present.\\n- `metadata.world_from_sensor` describes the coordinate convention.\\n  For world component `j`, take sensor component `axes[j]`, multiply by\\n  `signs[j]` and `meters_per_unit`, then add `origin_m[j]` for positions.\\n  Velocities use the same axis/sign/unit mapping without translation.\\n- `metadata.clock` defines elapsed seconds as\\n  `(tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick`.\\n- `metadata.analytic` gives initial position, initial velocity and constant\\n  acceleration in world metres and seconds.\\n- `observations` contains objects with `frame`, `tick`, `position`, and `velocity`.\\n  Input order is arbitrary. Some expected frames may be absent. The queried frame\\n  is present. Do not interpolate absent observations.\\n\\nReturn exactly `{\\\"ok\\\": true, \\\"report\\\": {...}}`. The report contains these fields:\\n\\n| Field | Required value |\\n| --- | --- |\\n| `source_sha256` | The provided original source digest |\\n| `frame` | The requested integer frame |\\n| `time_seconds` | Its elapsed time, after clock conversion |\\n| `position_m` | Its three world-coordinate position components |\\n| `speed_m_s` | Euclidean magnitude of its world velocity |\\n| `max_position_error_m` | Maximum Euclidean position error across **available** observations against `p0 + v0*t + 0.5*g*t*t` |\\n| `peak_frame` | Available frame with greatest world z; choose the lowest frame number on an exact tie |\\n| `peak_height_m` | That frame's world z position |\\n| `missing_frames` | Sorted list of expected but absent integer frames |\\n\\nUse JSON numbers for numerical values, never Boolean substitutes, NaN or Infinity.\\nChecks allow absolute numerical error up to 1e-6 or relative error up to 1e-7.\\nDo not infer metres, seconds, axis order, or completeness from filenames.\\n\\nThese inputs are derived representations of six real CUDA recordings published\\nby Robot Reel. Unit, coordinate, clock and omission variants are generated for this\\npublic development task. They are not new physical experiments or hidden test data.\\nReporting a source digest provides attribution; it does not authenticate the\\noriginal recording's producer.\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq6 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-6\n[tool_use read_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq7 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-7\n{\"ok\": true, \"content\": \"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    raise NotImplementedError(\\\"Convert recorded observations and return the requested facts\\\")\\n\\n\\nfor line in sys.stdin:\\n    print(json.dumps({\\\"ok\\\": True, \\\"report\\\": review(json.loads(line))}), flush=True)\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq8 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-8\n[tool_use write_file] {\"path\":\"/workspace/main.py\",\"content\":\"\\\"\\\"\\\"Implement the recording-review contract described in TASK.md.\\\"\\\"\\\"\\n\\nimport json\\nimport sys\\n\\n\\ndef review(request):\\n    # Extract the query frame\\n    query_frame = request[\\\"query_frame\\\"]\\n    recording = request[\\\"recording\\\"]\\n    source_sha256 = recording[\\\"source\\\"][\\\"sha256\\\"]\\n    metadata = recording[\\\"metadata\\\"]\\n    observations = recording[\\\"observations\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process metadata\\n    expected_frames = metadata[\\\"expected_frames\\\"]\\n    world_from_sensor = metadata[\\\"world_from_sensor\\\"]\\n    axes = world_from_sensor[\\\"axes\\\"]\\n    signs = world_from_sensor[\\\"signs\\\"]\\n    origin_m = world_from_sensor[\\\"origin_m\\\"]\\n    meters_per_unit = world_from_sensor[\\\"meters_per_unit\\\"]\\n    clock = metadata[\\\"clock\\\"]\\n    origin_tick = clock[\\\"origin_tick\\\"]\\n    seconds_per_tick = clock[\\\"seconds_per_tick\\\"]\\n    analytic = metadata[\\\"analytic\\\"]\\n    position0_m = analytic[\\\"position0_m\\\"]\\n    velocity0_m_s = analytic[\\\"velocity0_m_s\\\"]\\n    gravity_m_s2 = analytic[\\\"gravity_m_s2\\\"]\\n\\n    # Process observations\\n    observations_dict = {obs[\\\"frame\\\"]: obs for obs in observations}\\n    available_frames = sorted(observations_dict.keys())\\n\\n    # Calculate time_seconds for the query frame\\n    query_tick = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"tick\\\"]\\n    time_seconds = (query_tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n\\n    # Calculate position_m for the query frame\\n    query_position = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"position\\\"]\\n    position_m = [\\n        query_position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n        query_position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n        query_position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n    ]\\n\\n    # Calculate speed_m_s for the query frame\\n    query_velocity = observations_dict[query_frame][\\\"velocity\\\"]\\n    speed_m_s = (query_velocity[axes[0]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[1]] ** 2 + query_velocity[axes[2]] ** 2) ** 0.5\\n\\n    # Calculate max_position_error_m\\n    max_position_error_m = 0.0\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        tick = obs[\\\"tick\\\"]\\n        position = obs[\\\"position\\\"]\\n        # Convert position to world coordinates\\n        world_position = [\\n            position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n            position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n            position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n        ]\\n        # Calculate expected position using analytic model\\n        t = (tick - origin_tick) * seconds_per_tick\\n        expected_position = [\\n            position0_m[0] + velocity0_m_s[0] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[0] * t ** 2,\\n            position0_m[1] + velocity0_m_s[1] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[1] * t ** 2,\\n            position0_m[2] + velocity0_m_s[2] * t + 0.5 * gravity_m_s2[2] * t ** 2\\n        ]\\n        # Calculate position error\\n        error = (world_position[0] - expected_position[0]) ** 2 + (world_position[1] - expected_position[1]) ** 2 + (world_position[2] - expected_position[2]) ** 2\\n        error = error ** 0.5\\n        if error > max_position_error_m:\\n            max_position_error_m = error\\n\\n    # Find peak_frame and peak_height_m\\n    peak_frame = None\\n    peak_height_m = -float('inf')\\n    for frame in available_frames:\\n        obs = observations_dict[frame]\\n        position = obs[\\\"position\\\"]\\n        # Convert position to world coordinates\\n        world_position = [\\n            position[axes[0]] * signs[0] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[0],\\n            position[axes[1]] * signs[1] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[1],\\n            position[axes[2]] * signs[2] * meters_per_unit + origin_m[2]\\n        ]\\n        if world_position[2] > peak_height_m:\\n            peak_height_m = world_position[2]\\n            peak_frame = frame\\n        elif world_position[2] == peak_height_m:\\n            if frame < peak_frame:\\n                peak_frame = frame\\n\\n    # Find missing_frames\\n    missing_frames = []\\n    for frame in expected_frames:\\n        if frame not in observations_dict:\\n            missing_frames.append(frame)\\n    missing_frames.sort()\\n\\n    # Create report\\n    report = {\\n        \\\"source_sha256\\\": source_sha256,\\n        \\\"frame\\\": query_frame,\\n        \\\"time_seconds\\\": time_seconds,\\n        \\\"position_m\\\": position_m,\\n        \\\"speed_m_s\\\": speed_m_s,\\n        \\\"max_position_error_m\\\": max_position_error_m,\\n        \\\"peak_frame\\\": peak_frame,\\n        \\\"peak_height_m\\\": peak_height_m,\\n        \\\"missing_frames\\\": missing_frames\\n    }\\n    return report\\n\\n\\nfor line in sys.stdin:\\n    print(json.dumps({\\\"ok\\\": True, \\\"report\\\": review(json.loads(line))}), flush=True)\\n\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq9 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-9\n{\"ok\": true, \"written_bytes\": 4547}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] assistant seq10 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-10\n[tool_use run_command] {\"command\":\"python3 /workspace/main.py < /workspace/example.jsonl\"}\n---\n[2026-09-14T11:15:45.309261+00:00] tool seq11 turn=evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913-11\n{\"ok\": true, \"exit_code\": 0, \"output\": \"{\\\"ok\\\": true, \\\"report\\\": {\\\"source_sha256\\\": \\\"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\\\", \\\"frame\\\": 31, \\\"time_seconds\\\": 1.033333333333372, \\\"position_m\\\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \\\"speed_m_s\\\": 2004.6877195638112, \\\"max_position_error_m\\\": 0.02046407548115492, \\\"peak_frame\\\": 31, \\\"peak_height_m\\\": 6.085323333740234, \\\"missing_frames\\\": []}}\\n\", \"limit_reached\": null}\n---\nturns 5-11 of 14\n",
      "turns": [
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8,
        9,
        10,
        11
      ],
      "source": {
        "session_id": "evalarc-public-2f665fd5734bb89435224913",
        "manifest_sha256": "40ae2debeef57610aaacf01b4f086eba2b926cceece9bfcc81c6d051b121d925",
        "prior_trial_sha256": "2f665fd5734bb89435224913d43b4a69d91d53495c33d5ba9c375d2c59710004",
        "prior_program_sha256": "0f8d610ce4894ef43620e6f356a39c79775a09a4613b61e6e9818f34371bbf2a",
        "parquet_sha256": "4f38babfcd1c0fb84eac003667d0ac465f2024068c8616cc38a3da44e4f9ca4e"
      }
    }
  3. read_file
    {
      "path": "/workspace/main.py"
    }
  4. run_command
    {
      "command": "python3 /workspace/main.py < /workspace/example.jsonl"
    }
    Inspect command output
    {
      "ok": true,
      "exit_code": 0,
      "output": "{\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}\n",
      "limit_reached": null
    }
  5. run_command
    {
      "command": "python3 protocol_probe.py"
    }
    Inspect command output
    {
      "ok": true,
      "exit_code": 0,
      "output": "{\"protocol_ok\": true, \"requests\": 2, \"responses\": [{\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}, {\"ok\": true, \"report\": {\"source_sha256\": \"ed8caf612cae5c056d5a9f32b2074f1f7c6cdd1e50214b26ad70ebeaecb56b2e\", \"frame\": 31, \"time_seconds\": 1.033333333333372, \"position_m\": [2.066678047180176, 0.0, 6.085323333740234], \"speed_m_s\": 2004.6877195638112, \"max_position_error_m\": 0.02046407548115492, \"peak_frame\": 31, \"peak_height_m\": 6.085323333740234, \"missing_frames\": []}}], \"numerical_correctness\": \"not_assessed\"}\n",
      "limit_reached": null
    }
  6. finish
    {}
Inspect 4 failed cases
  • seed 41 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 41 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates
  • seed 97 / millimeters-sensor-frame: coordinates
  • seed 97 / centimeters-offset-clock: coordinates

Trial JSON · Program · Independent grade

Read operation counts in context

Command matches compare exact strings after trimming surrounding whitespace. Write matches compare normalized workspace paths and content hashes. The report separates matches with the prior session from repeats inside a continuation. Repeating a diagnostic can be necessary; fewer commands can also mean skipped checks. These counts do not estimate wasted work or human time saved.

Methods, failure controls and limits

Each attempt has up to 12 model turns, 4,096 generated tokens per turn and a 600-second interaction budget. Bridge startup and final grading are recorded separately. The same public protocol probe checks persistent JSONL responses in both conditions; numerical correctness comes from the independent grader.

Preflight controls exercise real Funes retrieval, an empty range, a rejected memory override and deliberate removal of the selected public Parquet. They are scripted checks, not extra agent trials. The exported prior session stores historical message strings; it does not reconstruct dedicated Funes tool-result blocks.

This is one public development task and one selected prior session. It does not establish general memory efficacy, held-out performance or native session restore in branded agent applications. Earlier handoff trials used pre-injected context and remain a separate experiment. No retries or successful-attempt filtering are used in this cohort.

Preselected plan · Every result · Reviewed model files · Retrieval model cache check · Offline verification · Record checksums